Gene mutations cause massive brain asymmetry

Hemimegalencephaly is a rare but dramatic condition in which the brain grows asymmetrically, with one hemisphere becoming massively enlarged. Though frequently diagnosed in children with severe epilepsy, the cause of hemimegalencephaly is unknown and current treatment is radical: surgical removal of some or all of the diseased half of the brain.
A team of doctors and scientists, led by researchers at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, say de novo somatic mutations in a trio of genes that help regulate cell size and proliferation are likely culprits for causing hemimegalencephaly, though perhaps not the only ones.
De novo somatic mutations are genetic changes in non-sex cells that are neither possessed nor transmitted by either parent. The scientists’ findings – a collaboration between Joseph G. Gleeson, MD, professor of neurosciences and pediatrics at UC San Diego School of Medicine and Rady Children’s Hospital-San Diego; Gary W. Mathern, MD, a neurosurgeon at UC Los Angeles’ Mattel Children’s Hospital; and colleagues – suggest it may be possible to design drugs that inhibit or turn down signals from these mutated genes, reducing or even preventing the need for surgery.
Gleeson’s lab studied a group of 20 patients with hemimegalencephaly upon whom Mathern had operated, analysing and comparing DNA sequences from removed brain tissue with DNA from the patients’ blood and saliva.
‘Mathern had reported a family with identical twins, in which one had hemimegalencephaly and one did not. Since such twins share all inherited DNA, we got to thinking that there may be a new mutation that arose in the diseased brain that causes the condition,’ said Gleeson. Realising they shared the same ideas about potential causes, the physicians set out to tackle this question using new exome sequencing technology, which allows sequencing of all of the protein-coding exons of the genome at the same time.
The researchers ultimately identified three gene mutations found only in the diseased brain samples. All three mutated genes had previously been linked to cancers.
‘We found mutations in a high percentage of the cells in genes regulating the cellular growth pathways in hemimegalencephaly,’ said Gleeson. ‘These same mutations have been found in various solid malignancies, including breast and pancreatic cancer. For reasons we do not yet understand, our patients do not develop cancer, but rather this unusual brain condition. Either there are other mutations required for cancer propagation that are missing in these patients, or neurons are not capable of forming these types of cancers.’
The mutations were found in 30 percent of the patients studied, indicating other factors are involved. Nonetheless, the researchers have begun investigating potential treatments that address the known gene mutations, with the clear goal of finding a way to avoid the need for surgery.
‘Although counterintuitive, hemimegalencephaly patients are far better off following the functional removal or disconnection of the enlarged hemisphere,’ said Mathern. ‘Prior to the surgery, most patients have devastating epilepsy, with hundreds of seizures per day, completely resistant to even our most powerful anti-seizure medications. The surgery disconnects the affected hemisphere from the rest of the brain, causing the seizures to stop. If performed at a young age and with appropriate rehabilitation, most children suffer less language or cognitive delay due to neural plasticity of the remaining hemisphere.’
But a less-invasive drug therapy would still be more appealing.
‘We know that certain already-approved medications can turn down the signaling pathway used by the mutated genes in hemimegalencephaly,’ said lead author and former UC San Diego post-doctoral researcher Jeong Ho Lee, now at the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology. ‘We would like to know if future patients might benefit from such a treatment. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if our results could prevent the need for such radical procedures in these children?’ EurekAlert

New gene expression test predicts benign disease in cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules

Each year, tens of thousands of patients have all or part of their thyroids removed to rule out cancer because of suspicious, but uncertain, cytology test results. In the majority of cases, the suspicious thyroid nodules are determined to be ultimately benign.
Now, new research led by Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH) finds that a novel, genomic diagnostic test that measures the expression of 167 genes has shown promise in improving pre-operative risk assessment by re-classifying otherwise indeterminate results from thyroid biopsies as either benign or suspicious.
‘Our findings show that the gene expression test can substantially reclassify otherwise inconclusive results from thyroid biopsies, said Erik Alexander, MD, lead author of the paper and a physician-researcher in the Division of Endocrinology, Diabetes and Hypertension at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. ‘Currently, indeterminate thyroid nodules are usually referred for thyroid surgery given the unanswered question of thyroid cancer. While all care should be personalised, our findings suggest that this test has the potential to drastically reduce unnecessary surgery and allow physicians to monitor many patients in a more conservative fashion.’
Thyroid nodules are common and ultrasound-guided needle biopsies (fine needle aspiration) have been shown to accurately identify about 65-75 percent of nodules as benign. Approximately five-10 percent of diagnostic biopsies are malignant. The remaining biopsies produce indeterminate results – occurring about fifteen to thirty percent of the time. For these patients, there remains substantial concern for thyroid cancer, though the diagnosis is uncertain. Because of the concern for cancer, in most cases, all or part of the thyroid is removed for final diagnosis. However, the nodule is ultimately benign in seventy to eighty percent of cases. For these patients, surgery was not needed and the patient was unnecessarily exposed to the cost, risk and morbidity associated with this intervention.
In this research study, researchers enrolled 3,789 patients and collected 4,812 thyroid samples from nodules larger than 1 cm and evaluated the effectiveness of a novel gene expression test in 265 thyroid samples that were cytologically indeterminate (suspicious for cancer, though not conclusive) from 49 different academic and community hospital sites around the United States. Samples were simultaneously collected for the standard-of-care cytology analysis, as well as one or two additional needle sticks for inclusion in the study. If the cytology result was indeterminate, the study sample was then analysed using the gene expression test. Thyroid surgery was performed based on the judgement of the treating physician who was blinded to the test results. At completion of the study, the gene expression test results were compared to final histopathology diagnosis (the gold-standard diagnosis) provided by two blinded pathology experts following their review of the surgical tissue sample.
For all cytologically indeterminate nodules, the researchers found that when the gene expression test was benign, histopathological analysis of the nodule proved it benign 93 percent of the time. And when applied to lower risk subgroups of indeterminate thyroid samples labelled ‘atypia (or follicular lesion) of an undetermined significance’ or ‘follicular neoplasm,’ the accuracy improved to 94 and 95 percent, respectively.
‘This very high negative predictive value is comparable to that of a cytologically benign cytology result. Therefore, such a result will allow clinicians to recommend a more conservative approach of watching waiting in lieu of diagnostic surgery,’ said Alexander. ‘It is estimated that over 50 percent of current thyroid surgeries are performed unnecessarily (for cytologically indeterminate, though histopathologically benign nodules), and therefore could be impacted by the gene expression test.’ Brigham and Women’s Hospital

Study finds genes associated with hippocampal atrophy

In a genome-wide association (GWA) study, researchers from Boston University Schools of Medicine (BUSM) and Public Health (BUSPH) have identified several genes which influence degeneration of the hippocampus, the part of the brain most associated with Alzheimer disease (AD). The study demonstrates the efficacy of endophenotypes for broadening the understanding of the genetic basis of and pathways leading to AD.
AD is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder for which there are no prevention methods. Available drugs only marginally affect disease severity and progression, making AD effectively untreatable.
GWA studies using very large samples have increased the number of robust associations to 10 genes, including APOE. However, these genes account for no more than 35 percent of the inherited risk of AD and most of the genetic underpinning of the disorder remains unexplained. According to the researchers, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain provides in vivo quantitative measures of neurodegenerative and cerebrovascular brain injury that may represent AD-related changes long before clinical symptoms appear. These measures are more powerful than comparisons of individuals with AD with cognitively healthy persons because they avoid misclassification of normal persons who will develop disease in the future.
BUSM researchers conducted a two-stage GWA study for quantitative measures of hippocampal volume (HV), total cerebral volume (TCV) and white matter hyperintensities (WMH). Brain MRI measures of HV, TCV and WMH were obtained from 981 Caucasian and 419 African-American AD cases and their cognitively normal siblings in the MIRAGE (Multi Institutional Research in Alzheimer’s Genetic Epidemiology) Study. In addition, similar MRI measures were obtained from 168 AD cases, 336 individuals with mild cognitive impairment and 188 controls (all Caucasian) in the AD Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) Study. The MIRAGE Caucasian families and ADNI subjects were included in the first stage and the MIRAGE African American families were added in stage two. Results from the two Caucasians data sets were combined by meta-analysis.
In stage two, one genetic marker (i.e. single nucleotide polymorphism or SNP) from each of the gene regions that were most significantly associated with AD in the Caucasian data sets was evaluated in the African-American data set.
Novel genome-wide significant associations were observed for HV with SNPs in the APOE, F5/SELP, LHFP, and GCFC2 gene regions. All of these associations were supported by evidence in each data set.
‘Our two-stage GWAS identified highly significant associations between a measure of degeneration in the brain region most strongly correlated with AD and several genes in both Caucasian and African American samples containing AD, cognitively impaired and cognitively healthy subjects. One of these associations was with the ε4 variant of APOE which is the most well-established genetic risk factor for AD. Other associations were demonstrated with markers in F5/SELP, LHFP, and GCFC2, genes not previously implicated in this disease’ explained senior author Lindsay Farrer, PhD, chief of biomedical genetics at BUSM. He also noted, ‘previous studies showed that blood level of P-selectin (the protein encoded by SELP) has been correlated with rate of cognitive decline in AD patients.’
Farrer believes it is very likely that the number and specificity of these associations will increase in future studies using larger samples and focused on additional precise structural and functional MRI measures. ‘These findings will inform experiments designed to increase our understanding of disease-causing mechanism and may lead to new therapeutics targets,’ added Farrer. Boston University Medical Center

New marker, new target in Ewing’s sarcoma

Ewing’s sarcoma is a bone cancer commonly diagnosed in about 250 U.S. teenagers per year. If early chemotherapy is effective, improvement can be durable. But for children and teens who respond poorly to a first attempt at chemotherapy or if the disease spreads, long-term survival can be less than 10 percent.
A University of Colorado Cancer Center study shows an important difference that may explain why some respond and some don’t: the existence of high levels of the protein EYA3.
‘First, levels of EYA3 could be a tool in offering an accurate prognosis and choosing how aggressively to treat Ewing’s Sarcoma, and second we hope that by lowering levels of EYA3, we could help increase the effectiveness of existing therapies for Ewing’s sarcoma,’ says Tyler Robin, PhD, first author of the recent paper.
Researchers recently defined the role of EYA3 as a DNA repair molecule and Tyler showed that EYA3 has a similar repair role in Ewing’s sarcoma – high levels of EYA3 help the tissue survive during and recover after treatment with chemotherapy. Importantly, when Robin knocked down EYA3 in Ewing’s sarcoma cells, they became sensitised to chemotherapy.
‘The genetic mutation that creates Ewing’s sarcoma also leads to high levels of EYA3,’ says Heide Ford, PhD, investigator at the CU Cancer Center and associate professor in the CU School of Medicine department of ob/gyn, and the paper’s senior author.
The mutation Ford refers to and that creates Ewing’s sarcoma is the fusion of a gene from chromosome 22 to a gene in chromosome 11. Known as a EWS/FLI translocation, this mutation turns off a cell’s ability to make another, intermediate step known as miR-708 – a molecule that helps to decide what parts of the genome do and don’t get read and manufactured into proteins. In healthy tissue, miR-708 turns off the production of EYA3; in Ewing’s sarcoma, miR-708 is down and so EYA3 is up.
‘Our next step is to test small molecule inhibitors against EYA3 to determine which inhibitors best sensitize Ewing’s sarcomas to chemotherapy,’ says Ford.
Robin and Ford hope that recognising EYA3 levels, reducing these levels directly, or intervening in the steps that lead to its over-production will help predict outcomes, make decisions about existing treatments, and eventually lead to new treatments for Ewing’s sarcoma. University of Colorado Cancer Center

The pluripotency factor LIN28 in monkey and human testis: a marker for spermatogonial stem cells?

Mammalian spermatogenesis is maintained by spermatogonial stem cells (SSCs). However, since evidentiary assays and unequivocal markers are still missing in non-human primates and man, the identity of primate SSCs is unknown. In contrast, in the mouse, germ cell transplantation studies functionally demonstrated the presence of SSCs. LIN28 is an RNA-binding pluripotent stem cell factor, which is also strongly expressed in undifferentiated mouse spermatogonia. By contrast, two recent reports indicated that LIN28 is completely absent from adult human testes. Here, we analysed LIN28 expression in marmoset monkey (Callithrix jacchus) and human testes during development and adulthood and compared it with the mouse. In the marmoset, LIN28 was strongly expressed in migratory PGCs and gonocytes. Strikingly, we found a rare LIN28-positive subpopulation of spermatogonia also in the adult marmoset testis. This was corroborated by western blotting and quantitative RT-PCR. Importantly, in contrast to previous publications, we found LIN28-positive spermatogonia also in normal adult human and additional adult non-human primate testes. Some seasonal breeders exhibit a degenerated (involuted) germinal epithelium during their non-breeding season consisting only of Sertoli cells and SSCs. The latter re-initiate spermatogenesis prior to the next breeding-season. Fully involuted testes from a seasonal hamster and NHP (Lemur catta) exhibited numerous LIN28-positive spermatogonia, indicating a SSC-identity of the labeled cells. We conclude that LIN28 is differentially expressed in mouse and non-human primate spermatogonia and might be a marker for a rare SSC population in non-human primates and man. Further characterization of the LIN28-positive population is required. European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology

Gene sequencing project identifies potential drug targets in common childhood brain tumour

Researchers studying the genetic roots of the most common malignant childhood brain tumour have discovered missteps in three of the four subtypes of the cancer that involve genes already targeted for drug development.
The most significant gene alterations are linked to subtypes of medulloblastoma that currently have the best and worst prognosis. They were among 41 genes associated for the first time to medulloblastoma by the St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital – Washington University Pediatric Cancer Genome Project.
‘This study provides new direction for understanding what drives these tumours and uncovers totally unexpected new drug targets. There are drugs already in development against these targets aimed at treating adult cancers and other diseases,’ said Richard Gilbertson, M.D., Ph.D., St. Jude Comprehensive Cancer Center director. Gilbertson and Jinghui Zhang, Ph.D., an associate member of the St. Jude Department of Computational Biology, are the study’s corresponding authors.
The results mark progress toward more targeted therapies against medulloblastoma and other cancers. While better use of existing drugs and improved supportive care have helped push long-term survival rates for childhood cancer to about 80 percent, drug development efforts have largely stalled for more than two decades, particularly against pediatric brain tumours.
‘This study is a great example of the way whole-genome sequencing of cancer patients allows us to dig deep into the biology of certain tumors and catch a glimpse of their Achilles heel,’ said co-author Richard K. Wilson, Ph.D., director of The Genome Institute at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis. ‘These results help us better understand the disease and, as a result, we will be able to more effectively diagnose and treat these kids.’
This study involved sequencing the complete normal and cancer genomes of 37 young patients with medulloblastoma, making it the largest such effort to date involving the cancer. Researchers then checked tumours from an additional 56 patients for the same alterations.
The findings are part of the Pediatric Cancer Genome Project, which launched in 2010 as a three-year effort to decipher the complete normal and tumour genomes of 600 young cancer patients with some of the most challenging tumours. The endeavour has already yielded important clues into the origin, spread and treatment response in childhood cancers of the blood, brain, eye and nervous system.
Medulloblastoma is diagnosed in about 400 U.S. children and adolescents annually. Their outcome varies widely based on the subtype they have. While nearly all patients with the wingless (WNT) subtype survive, just 60 percent of those with subtype 3 medulloblastoma are alive three years after diagnosis. WNT medulloblastoma is named for the pathway disrupted in the tumor subtype.
This study found a high percentage of patients with WNT-subtype medulloblastoma had mutations in the DDX3X gene. The investigators found evidence that mutated DDX3X is required to sustain the brain cells where WNT subtype tumours develop. The research also found evidence linking alterations in other genes, including CDH1 and PIK3CA, to the development and spread of the WNT subtype. ‘It is particularly exciting that these genes, or the pathways in which they work, are already the focus of drug development efforts. This opens up the possibility of using these drugs to treat medulloblastoma in new ways,’ said Giles Robinson, M.D., St. Jude Department of Oncology research associate and one of the study’s first authors.
Investigators demonstrated that subtype three and four medulloblastoma often had alterations in genes that impact cell maturation. The genes carry instructions for proteins that add or remove the chemical group methyl to the H3K27 protein. H3K27 is part of the chromatin structure that packages DNA to fit inside cells. That packaging helps determine if genes are switched on or off. The addition of methyl to H3K27 permits less specialised cells to keep dividing and blocks activity of genes that would prompt cells to stop dividing, differentiate and take on more specialised roles.
Some subgroup 3 and 4 tumours were characterised by a gain in EZH2, which adds methyl to H3K27. EZH2 is also associated with adult cancers and the focus of ongoing drug development. St. Jude has begun screening those and other compounds for evidence of effectiveness against medulloblastoma.
In other subtype 3 and 4 tumours a different gene, KDM6A, was inactivated by mutations. KDM6A works to remove methyl groups from H3K27, thus eliminating this gene’s function could keep cells in an immature dividing state. The results suggest the genes possibly work together to promote medulloblastoma development.
The EZH2 and KDM6A alterations were found only in the subgroup three and four tumours, which also had higher levels of H3K27 methylation than other medulloblastoma subtypes. ‘With this research we have ‘lifted the lid’ on the most aggressive and challenging form of medulloblastoma, subtype 3, which was really a black box in terms of our understanding, and revealed a major driver of the disease,’ Gilbertson said.
The findings add to mounting evidence from the Pediatric Cancer Genome Project that epigenetic changes play a pivotal role in fueling childhood cancer. Epigenetic mechanisms can serve as on-off switches, altering gene activity without changing the makeup of the gene. Such changes can lead to the unlimited cell growth of cancer. St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital

Researchers isolate gene mutations in patients with inherited amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

A new genetic mutation that causes familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), a fatal neurological disorder also known as Lou Gehrig’s Disease, has been identified by a team of scientists led by researchers at the University of Massachusetts Medical School (UMMS). Mutations to the profilin (PFN1) gene, which is essential to the growth and development of nerve cell axons, is estimated to account for one to two percent of inherited ALS cases. The finding points to defects in a neuron’s cytoskeleton structure as a potential common feature among diverse ALS genes.
‘This discovery identifies what may possibly be a common biological mechanism involved across familial ALS cases regardless of genetics,’ said John Landers, PhD, associate professor of neurology and senior author of the study. ‘We know of at least three other ALS genes, in addition to PFN1, that adversely impact axon growth. If indeed, this is part of the disease’s mechanism, then it might also be a potential target for therapeutics.’
Robert Brown, MD, DPhil, a co-author on the study and chair of neurology at UMass Medical School, said ‘Dr. Landers has done great work in defining this new pathway for motor neuron death. We are delighted to have identified the defects in families from the U.S., Israel and France that we have been investigating for several years. Our finding is particularly exciting because it may provide new insights into ALS treatment targets.’
ALS is a progressive, neurodegenerative disorder affecting the motor neurons in the central nervous system. As motor neurons die, the brain’s ability to send signals to the body’s muscles is compromised. This leads to loss of voluntary muscle movement, paralysis and eventually respiratory failure. The cause of most cases of ALS is not known. Approximately 10 percent of cases are inherited. Though investigators at UMass Medical School and elsewhere have identified several genes shown to cause inherited or familial ALS, almost 50 percent of these cases have an unknown genetic cause.
The current study details the discovery of the PFN1 gene mutation among two large ALS families. Both families were negative for known ALS-causing mutations and displayed familial relationships that suggested a dominant inheritance mode for the disease. For each family, two affected members with maximum genetic distance were selected for deep DNA sequencing. To identify an ALS-causing mutation, genetic variations between the family members were identified and screened against known databases of human genetic variation, such as the 1000 Genomes Project. This narrowed down the resulting number of candidate, ALS-causing mutations to two within the first family and three within the second. Interestingly, both families contained different mutations within the same gene – PFN1, the likely causative mutation. With additional screening, the team documented that in a total of 274 families sequenced, seven contained a mutation to the PFN1 gene, establishing it as a likely cause for ALS.
While it is not certain how the PFN1 mutation causes ALS, the cellular functions it controls within the motor neurons are responsible for regulation of a number of activities, including the growth and development of the axon, the slender projection through which neurons transmit electrical impulses to neighboring cells, such as muscle. When introduced into motor neuron cells, normal PFN1 protein was found diffused throughout the cytoplasm. Conversely, the mutant PFN1 observed in ALS patients was found to collect in dense aggregates, keeping it from functioning properly. Motor neurons producing mutated PFN1 showed markedly shorter axon outgrowth.
‘The discovery that mutant PFN1 interferes with axon outgrowth was very exciting to us,’ said Claudia Fallini, PhD, a postdoctoral researcher at Emory University School of Medicine who collaborated with the UMass Medical School authors to investigate PFN1’s functions in cultured motor neurons. ‘It suggests that alterations in actin dynamics may be an important mechanism at the basis of motor neuron degeneration.’
‘In healthy neurons, PFN1 acts almost like a railroad tie for fibrous filaments called actin, which make up the axon’ said Landers. ‘PFN1 helps bind these filaments to each other, promoting outgrowth of the axon. Without properly functioning PFN1 these filaments can’t come together. Here we show that mutant PFN1 may contribute to ALS pathogeneses by accumulating in these aggregates and altering the actin dynamics in a way that inhibits axon outgrowth.’ EurekAlert

Mutation in gene IDH a possible target for AML treatment

Many patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML) share a mutation in a gene called IDH. A University of Colorado Cancer Center study shows that this IDH mutation may be the first domino in a chain that leads to a more aggressive form of the disease.
‘In fact, it’s not IDH itself that causes the problem,’ says Dan Pollyea, MD, MS, investigator at the CU Cancer Center and assistant professor of haematologic oncology at the University of Colorado School of Medicine. Rather, the mutation in IDH leads to exponentially higher blood levels of a protein called 2-hydroxyglutarate. This protein ‘mucks up,’ as Pollyea says, other genes that in turn promote cancer or fail to inhibit its growth.
The recent study shows that AML patients in remission who retain high levels of 2-hydroxyglutarate – due universally to IDH mutation – are much more likely to relapse than patients without similarly elevated levels.
The chain of causation includes another couple links.
‘2-hydroxyglutarate reduces genes’ ability to regulate themselves,’ says Pollyea. Over time genes accumulate gunk in the form of methylation – these methyl groups attach to silence parts of gene promoters, helping to decide which genes are and are not turned into proteins. Too much methylation is associated with many cancers, including AML. And 2-hydroxyglutarate turns off one of the body’s methylation-regulating genes.
So an IDH mutation leads to high 2-hydroxyglutarate, leads to bad gene regulation, leads to hypermethylation, leads to AML.
Pollyea hopes to stop the first domino from falling by targeting IDH mutations. ‘Imagine screening for patients prospectively and then if they have the mutation, we could use something like an IDH inhibitor,’ Pollyea says. Turn off this mutation and doctors may be able to turn of the disease, or at least its most aggressive characteristics.
But the genetic testing for IDH mutation is currently costly and time consuming. And so Pollyea hopes to identify patients with the IDH mutation by looking downstream – tests for blood-levels of 2-hydroxyglutarate being developed at the CU Cancer Center could determine the patients most likely to benefit from an IDH inhibitor.
Finally, Pollyea and colleagues including molecular biologist James DeGregori, PhD, are exploring novel ways to target the IDH mutation. ‘I think that even beyond the very real promise of IDH inhibitor drugs, this is a potential weak spot for AML that can be targeted in a number of ways,’ Pollyea says. University of Colorado Cancer Center

Evolutionary information improves discovery of mutations associated with diseases

A book containing misprints may cause annoyance for the reader, but typos in an individual’s genetic blueprint (DNA) can mean serious disease or even death. The search for genetic correlates for the wide range of diseases plaguing humankind has inspired a wealth of research falling under the heading of genome-wide association studies (GWAS).
According to Sudhir Kumar, director of the Center for Evolutionary Medicine and Informatics at Arizona State University’s Biodesign Institute, however, results from many such studies become less useful when gene variants or alleles implicated in disease in a given population fail to be discovered in subsequent independent studies. ‘Often, we do not discover the same set of mutations for the same disease in different populations,’ he says. ‘This is a huge problem in genomic medicine.’
Kumar and colleagues Joel T. Dudley, Rong Chen, Maxwell Sanderford, and Atul J. Butte, have developed a statistical method to remedy this problem by using evolutionary information. It is capable of significantly enhancing the likelihood of identifying disease-associated alleles that show better consistency across populations, improving the reliability of GWAS studies. The method makes use of phylogenetics – the comparative study of species genomes through long-term evolutionary history.
The new method is now available to use via the web, so that researchers worldwide can apply it as an aid to discovering disease-associated mutations that are more consistently reproducible and therefore useable as diagnostic markers. Kumar refers to this new approach, combining standard comparative genomic studies with phylogenetic data as phylomedicine, a rapidly developing field that promises to streamline genomic information and improve its diagnostic power.
‘We can take this method and apply it to all the data that has been published,’ Kumar says. ‘It will lead to new discoveries that were sitting right there, but nobody knew about.’
The new method boosts the discovery of reproducible mutations by integrating evolutionary history of humans with contemporary genomic information. Applying the new rankings to a large GWAS study improved the discovery of reliable mutation correlates of complex diseases, which will advance personalised medicine based on each patient’s genomic code.
The basic idea behind GWAS is simple: compare the genomes of two populations of subjects, one with disease trait and a control group without the disease. Next, identify the disparities at each position of the genome in the two populations. Find the alleles occurring in the diseased population that are less frequent in the healthy population and you have just pinpointed the gene mutations associated with disease.
Or have you?
As Kumar explains, matters are not so simple. The mutations studied in such studies are known as SNPs (for single-nucleotide polymorphisms). This simply means that for a given gene sequence, one of the four nucleotides (A,T,C and G) found commonly in the population is replaced by something else. For example, the majority of healthy subjects may carry the ‘A’ at a particular position in the genome, but disease individuals may be more likely to carry a ‘C’ at the same position. If the difference between the groups is striking, the SNP may be associated with the disease trait.
Human genomes are vast structures – consisting of some 3 billion base pairs of nucleotides. Most are littered with SNPs and teasing out which ones sit there without apparent effect and which may translate to disease is often a vexing affair. For some diseases, a one-to-one correspondence between gene mutation and disease exists. Generally, these afflictions, known as monogenic diseases, have particular characteristics. They result from a mutation in just a single gene, rather than multiple genes. They are early-onset diseases, taking their toll when the patient is still young.
Monogenic diseases, which include cystic fibrosis, Tay sachs disease, sickle cell anemia and Huntington’s disease are usually not the targets for genome-wide association studies, because the relationship between gene mutation and occurrence of the disease is straightforward and reliable.
By contrast, so-called complex diseases tend to occur later in life, are triggered by mutations occurring at multiple sites along the genome and often have a significant environmental– that is, non-genetic – component. Finding the alleles responsible for such diseases, which include hypertension, rheumatoid arthritis, Alzheimer’s disease, type II diabetes and countless others through GWAS studies has often been a bewildering endeavor, as alleles identified in one study population frequently fail to turn up in different studies with different populations.
GWAS studies compute the odds of an allele along the genome being disease-related and translate this into a statistic known as the P value. Alleles with the lowest P value are least likely to have occurred by random chance. In the current research, a meta-analysis is conducted using results from thousands of previous GWAS studies and phylogenetics are applied to unearth evolutionary trends in the data.
‘Every position in the human genome among the billions of base pairs has evolved over time,’ Kumar says. ‘As the genome evolves, some positions permit change frequently while others do not.’ The positions least likely to change with time and across mammalian species are known as evolutionarily conserved positions. The group conducted a multispecies genomic analysis of 5,831 putative human risk variants for more than 230 disease phenotypes reported in 2,021 studies. ‘Even if a GWAS variant does not have a functional role in a disease, evolutionary information is still very relevant, because every position in the human genome has an evolutionary signature that gives us prior information on how alleles at that position are likely to vary in modern human populations,’ says Dudley, the study’s lead author.
An analysis of existing data found that most of the presumptively disease-related alleles uncovered in the GWAS studies occurred at relatively slow-evolving, highly conserved sites. According to Kumar, this fact accounts for the poor reproducibility of many putative disease alleles across different populations, as alleles occurring at conserved sites tend to be rare. As Kumar explains ‘You can keep finding rare alleles like this all day, but they would have limited clinical utility in a broader population.’
The new ranking system, known as E-ranking, incorporates phylogenetic information from multi-species studies of mammals, and applies it to human GWAS data. The effect is to remove the inherent sampling bias for rare alleles, allowing the more common alleles occurring at fast-evolving sites in the genome to be more readily discovered. ‘Our method removes this bias, which gives a boost to high-frequency common variants that are more likely to reproduce across populations due to the evolutionary history of the genomic position where they are found,’ says Dudley. Arizona State University

Researchers link Kawasaki Disease in childhood with increased risk of adult heart disease

Cedars-Sinai researchers have linked Kawasaki Disease, a serious childhood illness that causes inflammation of blood vessels throughout the body, with early-onset and accelerated atherosclerosis, a leading cause of heart disease in adults.
In a study, an American Heart Association peer-reviewed medical journal, a team of researchers showed how Kawasaki Disease in young mice predisposed them to develop accelerated atherosclerosis, often called hardening of the arteries, in young adulthood. The study also suggests that aggressive early treatment of the blood vessel inflammation caused by Kawasaki Disease may reduce the future risk of developing accelerated atherosclerosis. Up to 25 percent of children with Kawasaki Disease will develop inflammation of the coronary arteries, making it the leading cause of acquired heart disease among children in developed countries.
‘Heart disease is the leading cause of death in this country and this study suggests that adult cardiovascular diseases likely start during childhood and that Kawasaki Disease may play a role in the childhood origin of adult heart disease,’ said Moshe Arditi, MD, executive vice chair of research in Cedars-Sinai’s Department of Pediatrics in the Maxine Dunitz Children’s Health Center and director of the Division of Pediatric Infectious Diseases and Immunology. ‘By recognising the connection between this vascular inflammatory disease and hardening of the arteries in young adults, physicians will be better prepared to provide preventive care to these vulnerable patients.’
Arditi said the study’s findings also may have implications for children with Kawasaki Disease in that they may need to be closely monitored for future development of early-onset atherosclerosis. Also, doctors treating children who have had Kawasaki Disease should closely monitor other known cardiovascular disease risk factors such as obesity, high blood pressure, high cholesterol and smoking, Arditi said.
Kawasaki Disease is diagnosed in approximately 5,000 U.S. children every year, predominantly affecting children younger than five. Boys are more likely than girls to acquire Kawasaki Disease, which starts with a sudden, persistent fever and causes swollen hands and feet, red eyes and body rash. Scientists suspect Kawasaki Disease is the body’s immune reaction to a virus that has yet to be identified.
Atherosclerosis occurs when fat, cholesterol, and other substances build up in the walls of arteries and form hard structures called plaques. Over the course of years, plaque buildup makes it harder for blood to flow because the plaque narrows arteries and makes them stiffer. When pieces of plaque break off and move to smaller vessels, they can cause stroke, heart attack or pulmonary embolism.
In the study, which was funded with a grant from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, mice with Kawasaki Disease were fed a high-fat diet and then compared to mice that did not have Kawasaki Disease but did eat the same high-fat diet. The Kawasaki mice developed significantly more atherosclerotic plaque at a younger age.
‘This study suggests that timely diagnosis and aggressive initial treatment of the vascular inflammation may be important in preventing this potentially serious future complication,’ said co-author Prediman K. Shah, MD, director of cardiology, director of the and the Shapell and Webb Family Chair in Clinical Cardiology at the Cedars-Sinai Heart Institute. EurekAlert