MEETING REPORT: Circulating Biomarkers 2015

The Beatson Institute of Cancer Research, Bearsden, Glasgow, hosted ‘Circulating Biomarkers 2015’, a Biotexcel conference and workshop. The role of circulating biomarkers in early diagnosis and treatment monitoring is gaining momentum with kits for analysing DNA and RNA from circulating tissue already on the market, and liquid biopsy products in development. The analysis of circulating biomarkers allows less expensive and less invasive screening of patients, and so would enable the early diagnosis of disease and hence timely treatment, for example in pancreatic cancer where presentation typically occurs too late for a cure to be achieved. Also, monitoring of treatment in, for example, breast cancer patients by screening of circulating tumour cells will allow clinicians to make better and quicker decisions about the best therapy for the patient.
In the now familiar format, the meeting included a mix of lectures, a networking workshop, a panel debate, and technology presentations.  The lectures included, among others, presentations on the analysis of circulating tumour DNA (Prof. Charles Coombes, Imperial College London, UK; Dr Gerhardt Attard, Institute of Cancer Research and the Royal Marsden, Surrey, UK), RNA (Prof. Sue Burchill, Leeds Institute of Cancer and Pathology, UK), circulating tumour cells (CTCs) (Dr Vera Cappelletti, National Cancer Institute, Milan, Italy; Dr François-Clément Bidard, Institut Curie, Paris, France) and micro RNA (Dr Alberto Rocci, Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester, UK). Other talks discussed the potential of metabolomic biomarkers in cancer (Dr Oliver Maddocks, Beatson Institute for Cancer Research, Glasgow, UK) and how to use a variety of biomarkers and other parameters for the evaluation of the complex  situation of ageing and lifespan (Prof. Paul Shiels, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK).
The technology presentations included talks on technology for the enrichment of circulating cell-free DNA (Dr Vipulkumar Patel, Analytik Jena), coupling the CellSearch system (CellSearch) and DEPArray platform (Silicon Biosystems) to isolate single CTCs (by Dr Francesca Fontana (Silicon Biosystems) and targeted biomarker detection by MassARRAY (Dr Malcolm Plant, Agena Bioscience).
The panel debate was centred around the question, ‘CTCs vs. cfDNA vs. miRNA vs. mRNA: which is better and why?’ but perhaps the more interesting discussion that evolved was on the ethics of biomarker analysis (Is it ethical to screen for a condition where there is no treatment ?) and the practicalities of screening (How do we screen for conditions that need to be caught before the presentation of symptoms?). Additionally, the meeting provided many networking opportunities and the benefit of such discussion will, no doubt, be borne out by the development and continuation of new and existing collaborations. A very profitable meeting for all involved.

Studying cancer DNA in blood may help personalize treatment in liver cancer

Fragments of cancer DNA circulating in a patient’s bloodstream could help doctors deliver more personalized treatment for liver cancer, Japanese researchers report.

The new research may help address a particular challenge posed by liver cancers, which can be difficult to analyse safely. One serious risk of existing biopsy methods is that doctors who want to obtain a tumour sample for analysis might cause the cancer to spread into the space around organs.

‘Doctors need non-invasive methods that will allow them to safely study cancer progression and characterize the genomic features of a patient’s tumour,’ said Professor Kazuaki Chayama, a principal investigator in this study. ‘Testing for these circulating DNA fragments may be a much easier and safer way of doing this than conventional liver biopsy.’

The researchers showed that detecting DNA released by damaged cancer cells, called circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA), in serum before surgery could predict the recurrence of cancer and its spread through the body (metastasis) in patients with an advanced form of the most common type of liver cancer. They also demonstrated that the level of serum ctDNA reflected the treatment effect and the progression of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC).

Recent studies have suggested that ctDNA might be a useful biomarker in various cancers. The new study brings this technique closer to clinical reality in patients with advanced HCC by showing that ctDNA provided valuable clinical information about the patient’s disease progression.

Professor Chayama and colleagues in Hiroshima University including Dr. Atsushi Ono, together with researchers at RIKEN and the University of Tokyo, investigated whether they could detect ctDNA in serum of 46 HCC patients. They found ctDNA in seven patients. These patients were more likely than the others to experience recurrence and metastasis of their cancer. ‘Furthermore, we found that the level of ctDNA correlated with progression of HCC and the treatment,’ said Professor Chayama.

The Japanese team also says that ctDNA has the potential to be a non-invasive way of studying the genetic rearrangements that a cancer has undergone. This information could help doctors provide targeted therapy specific to a patient’s cancer, they note.

Recently, detection of cancer-specific mutations by genome sequencing has attracted attention as a way to help select appropriate therapy selection, Professor Chayama said. The researchers were able to identify 25 common mutations in samples of cell-free DNA, which includes DNA from both normal cells and cancer cells, and DNA from tumours themselves. Furthermore, 83% of mutations identified in the tumour tissues could be detected in the cell-free DNA.

Although further study is necessary to develop more effective methods, the new study adds to growing evidence about the usefulness of ctDNA in cancer treatment, and shows that it is a promising biomarker that provides a new way to treat liver cancer. EurekAlert

The role played by the genome in eczema

The largest genetic study of atopic dermatitis ever performed permitted a team of international researchers to identify ten previously unknown genetic variations that contribute to the development of the condition. The researchers also found evidence of genetic overlap between atopic dermatitis and other illnesses, including inflammatory bowel disease.

Atopic dermatitis, a type of eczema, afflicts approximately one out of every five children and one out of every twelve adults. Though knowledge of the genome is crucial to assessing the likelihood that an individual will develop atopic dermatitis, most genes responsible for the condition have not yet been discovered.

The team of international researchers that conducted the largest genetic study of atopic dermatitis to this point pooled data obtained from 377,000 subjects in 40 different projects around the world.

 “We identified ten new genetic variations, making a total of 31 that are currently known to be associated with atopic dermatitis,” says Bo Jacobsson, a professor at Sahlgrenska Academy who was a member of the team. “Of particular interest is that each of the new ones has a role to play in regulation of the immune system.”
The researchers found evidence of genetic overlap between atopic dermatitis and other illnesses, including inflammatory bowel disease.

 “While the new variations contribute in only a small way to the risk of developing atopic dermatitis, knowing about them will raise our awareness about the mechanisms of the various diseases,” Professor Jacobsson says. “Our ultimate hope is that additional treatment methods will emerge as a result.”
Although the importance of genetic factors in the pathogenesis of atopic dermatitis had already been established, the sheer size of this study allowed researchers to fine tune their understanding and obtain more information about the ways that autoimmune mechanisms run amok as the disease develops.

A total of 21,399 cases of European, African, Japanese and Latino ancestry were first compared in 22 different studies with 95,464 controls. The findings were then replicated in 18 studies of 32,059 cases and 228,628 controls.

“Multi-ancestry genome-wide association study of 21,000 cases and 95,000 controls identifies new risk loci for atopic dermatitis” was published in Nature Genetics online on October 19. University of Gothenburg

A newly-discovered tumour suppressor gene affects melanoma survival

Of the hundreds of genes that can be mutated in a single case of melanoma, only a handful may be true “drivers” of cancer. A Weizmann Institute of Science team has now revealed one of the drivers of a particularly deadly subset of melanomas – one that is still seeing a rise in new cases. This gene is a newly identified member of a group of genes called tumour suppressor genes. It is mutated in some 5.4% of melanomas. Furthermore, its expression was found to be lost in over 30% of human melanomas; and this loss, according to the finding, was associated with reduced patient survival. This discovery might open new doors to understanding how this cancer grows and spreads, and it may lead in the future to new directions in treating this disease.

Prof. Yardena Samuels and her team in the Institute’s Molecular Cell Biology Department were specifically searching for tumour suppressor genes in their database, which consists of more than 500 melanoma genomes and exomes – protein-building sequences – making it the largest melanoma dataset to date. As their name suggests, tumour suppressor genes normally inhibit cell growth, including that of cancer cells. However, when mutated, they act like defective brakes on cellular proliferation. Thus studying these genes is crucial in cancer biology. “The identification of targetable alterations in melanoma is an urgent need. An in-depth understanding of the functional effects of mutations in these genes is the first step toward revealing the underlying mechanism of melanoma growth,” says Dr. Nouar Qutob, a postdoctoral fellow in Samuels’ lab who participated in this research.

Indeed, the melanoma genome sequences contained mutations in known tumour suppressor genes, but there was also a new gene that stood out in the team’s search, named RASA2. The researchers’ next step was to conduct a series of functional experiments to understand exactly what this gene does. They cloned both the normal protein and the most recurrent mutated versions to see their effects on melanoma cells. They found that RASA2 regulates a key protein in the cell, called RAS. RAS has been identified as a major oncogene that contributes to the unchecked growth of cells. When they restored the production of the protein in melanoma cells that harboured RASA2 mutations, these cells stopped growing and eventually died.

Patients with dysfunctional RAS pathways tend to have a worse prognosis than those with other types of melanoma, and, until now, scientists have not managed to create drugs that can target this pathway. “As the RAS pathway is highly dysregulated in cancer, the discovery of an alternative mechanism for its activation is likely to stimulate an avalanche of further research in this field, and is highly likely to have direct clinical relevance. We are now going to focus on RASA2, to find out what proteins it communicates with in healthy cells and melanoma, as well as in the cells’ response to targeted therapy,” says Samuels. Weizmann Insititute

Molecular ‘brake’ stifles human lung cancer

Scientists at the Salk Institute have uncovered a molecule whose mutation leads to the aggressive growth of a common and deadly type of lung cancer in humans.

This enzyme, called EphA2, normally polices a gene responsible for tissue growth. But when EphA2 is mutated, the Salk team discovered, cellular systems can run amok and quickly develop tumours. The new work suggests that EphA2 could be a new target for a subset of lung cancer, which affects non-smokers as well as smokers, and is the leading cause of cancer-related deaths worldwide.

 “Sometimes there are hundreds of mutations in the genes of a patient’s tumors, but you don’t know whether they are drivers of the disease or by-products,” says senior author Inder Verma, professor of genetics and holder of Salk’s Irwin and Joan Jacobs Chair in Exemplary Life Science. “We found a new way by which to identify cancer suppressor genes and understand how they could be targeted for therapies.”

Two gene mutations in particular are known to spur the growth of human tumours: KRAS and p53. Though both genes have been heavily studied, they are difficult to therapeutically target, so the Salk team decided to look at genes that might police KRAS and p53 instead.

The researchers narrowed in on the 4,700 genes in the human genome related to cellular signalling–specifically, genes that have the ability to tamp down cell growth and proliferation. Then the team adapted a genetic screening technique to quickly and efficiently test the effect of these thousands of genes on tumour development. In animal models, the Salk team found that 16 of these cell-signalling genes produced molecules that had a significant effect on KRAS- and p53-related tumours.

Of these 16 molecules, one especially stood out: the EphA2 enzyme, originally discovered in the lab of another Salk scientist, Tony Hunter. Previously, EphA2’s significance in lung cancer was unclear, but the team discovered that its absence let KRAS-associated tumours grow much more aggressively.

“With a mutation in KRAS, a tumour forms in 300 days. But without EphA2, the KRAS mutation leads to tumours in half the time, 120 to 150 days,” says Verma, who is also an American Cancer Society Professor of Molecular Biology. “This molecule EphA2 is having a huge effect on restraining cancer growth when KRAS is mutated.” Mutated KRAS is a common culprit in approximately 10 to 20 percent of all cancers, particularly colon cancer and human lung cancer.

 “Since activating EphA2 led to the suppression of both cell signalling and cell proliferation, we believe that the enzyme might serve as a potential drug target in KRAS-dependent lung adenocarcinoma,” says Narayana Yeddula, a Salk research associate and first author of the paper. Salk Institute for Biological Studies

Genetic key to why some lymphoma patients don’t respond to treatment

An important regulator that controls the ability of tumour cells to hide from the immune system in lymphoma patients, making them unlikely to respond to standard treatment, has been discovered by scientists at the University of Oxford.

Researchers analysed tumour samples from individual patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL), alongside cell line models and data on treatment response and survival.

DLBCL, an aggressive cancer affecting white blood cells, is diagnosed in around 5,000 people each year in the UK. There are several different subtypes of the disease, each of which differs in its response to chemotherapy.

The Oxford team found that high levels of shortened forms of a protein, known as FOXP1, in a patient’s lymphoma cells enable the cancer to evade the immune system, potentially nearly halving survival rates for these patients.

The shortened form of the FOXP1 protein was shown to block molecular ‘red flags’ on the surface of lymphoma cells, that would normally present tumour markers to immune cells in the blood – thus blocking the body’s natural defence against cancer.   

An aggressive subtype of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma that affects around a half of all patients is known to have abundant shorter forms of the FOXP1 protein. There are a number of drugs currently being developed for this disease subtype, and these findings could add crucial information.

Professor Alison Banham, from the University of Oxford, said: “Scientists have been trying to understand the mechanism of this loss of immune system recognition for over a decade. Now we know that the FOXP1 protein has such an impact on how this type of lymphoma progresses, we can design drugs to switch off the FOXP1 gene in lymphoma cells and help patients’ immune systems to fight their tumour.”

When the scientists prevented the FOXP1gene from functioning in the laboratory, they found that levels of a group of proteins involved in cell interaction with the immune system were raised. Levels of one particular protein in this group, HLA-DRA (a major histocompatibility class II protein), rose significantly as levels of FOXP1 dropped in tumour cells.

The researchers then analysed the tumour profiles of 150 patients with DLBCL who had undergone standard treatment – a combination of chemotherapy and antibody drugs. While 72% of patients with high levels of the HLA-DRA protein survived for over five years after diagnosis, just 38% of patients with lower levels of the protein in their lymphoma cells survived that long. Scientists believe that blocking FOXP1can elevate HLA-DRA, which in turn helps the immune system to keep the lymphoma at bay. Oxford University

Steps forward in the hunt for easily measurable biomarkers of autism

Future Science Group (FSG) have announced the publication of a new article in Future Science OA, reporting data demonstrating the possibility of measuring 10 biomarkers relevant to autism spectrum disorder in adult saliva.

With more than 70 biomarkers shown to be of relevance to autism, it is doubtful that a single biomarker will be of use in diagnosis and determination of severity. As such, it is important to develop a clinically relevant and measurable panel of biomarkers. Saliva presents an intriguing opportunity, as it is non-invasive and considered less stressful for patients than collection of urine or blood.

The study, by Helen V Ratajczak (Edmond Enterprises, CT, USA) and Robert B Sothern (University of Minnesota, MN, USA), analysed levels of 10 biomarkers previously noted to be pertinent to autism in saliva from 12 neurotypical, healthy adults. The utilized method was developed with simplicity in mind, with a view towards enabling future testing in autistic adults and, potentially, in children.

“This research is timely, as we desperately need biomarkers of autism spectrum disorder,” commented Francesca Lake, Managing Editor. “The findings, while preliminary, bring us a step closer to our ultimate goal of being effectively able to diagnose and treat autism. We look forward to further studies in more patients, and in those affected by autism.”

“Saliva was chosen because its collection causes the least stress (and the least effect on biomarker concentration),” explained Ratajczak. “Similar results were obtained when 6 men and 6 women read instructions, and an hour later after having instructions given by the principal investigator. Therefore, saliva can be collected by literate individuals without added instruction.  In addition, the elapse of an hour between collections did not significantly alter marker concentrations.” The researchers hope to design future studies to further this research, looking to aid diagnosis of autism and determination of severity, and brings us closer to a subject-specific treatment. Future Science

New technique could expand number of diseases detected by non=invasive prenatal testing

Researchers at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine developed a method to expand the types of chromosomal abnormalities that non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT) can detect. The study uses a semiconductor sequencing platform to identify small chromosomal deletions or duplications, such as occur in Cri du Chat Syndrome and DiGeorge Syndrome, with a simple blood test from the expectant mother.
Detecting these types of small chromosomal abnormalities with conventional techniques usually requires an invasive procedure to obtain foetal DNA, such as amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling. These procedures carry a small but concerning risk for miscarriage and infection. Since the recent discovery that foetal DNA can be found in the blood of pregnant women, NIPT has been increasingly used to detect certain chromosomal abnormalities through a maternal blood test. So far, though, NIPT is typically used only to detect abnormalities that result from larger chromosomal abnormalities — too many or too few of a particular chromosome, for example, such as occurs in Down syndrome.

“We have found that NIPT can be extended in a way that allows us to zoom in and examine a small segment of a chromosome,” said Kang Zhang, MD, PhD, professor of ophthalmology and chief of Ophthalmic Genetics at UC San Diego School of Medicine, who led the study with collaborators in China. “And while this study focused on cell-free DNA sequencing in pregnant women, this method could be applied more broadly to other genetic diagnoses, such as analysing circulating tumour DNA for detection of cancer.”
Zhang and his team analysed blood plasma from 1,476 pregnant women with foetal structural abnormalities detected by ultrasound. These women also underwent an invasive diagnostic procedure and conventional foetal DNA analysis. The researchers compared that information to semiconductor sequencing results on circulating foetal DNA obtained from a blood test on the pregnant women at an average gestational age of 24 weeks. The new semiconductor sequencing method detected 69 of 73 (94.5 percent) of abnormalities of a certain size (greater than one million base pairs) detected by the conventional method.

According to the researchers, the cost of NIPT with semiconductor sequencing has the potential to be less expensive than the conventional, invasive prenatal testing method, especially as genetic sequencing technologies continue to decrease in cost.

While promising, there is still need for improvement before this NIPT application can be used clinically. In the study, semiconductor sequencing detected 55 false positives, of which 35 (63.6 percent) were due to maternal, rather than foetal, chromosomal abnormalities. That means the new method will require a validation test to screen out maternal abnormalities.

NIPT with semiconductor sequencing also needs to be tested at early time points in the pregnancy — at 12 to 16 weeks — and the researchers hope to further improve the technique to be able to detect even smaller genetic abnormalities.
The problem is that the more variations they are able to detect, the more they are likely to pick up chromosomal deletions or duplications of unknown clinical significance or with mild clinical consequences. Many of the abnormalities detected could be normal inherited variations. UC San Diego Health

New way to find DNA damage

University of Utah chemists devised a new way to detect chemical damage to DNA that sometimes leads to genetic mutations responsible for many diseases, including various cancers and neurological disorders.

“We are one step closer to understanding the underlying chemistry that leads to genetic diseases,” says Cynthia Burrows, distinguished professor and chair of chemistry at the university. “We have a way of marking and copying DNA damage sites so that we can preserve the information of where and what the damage was.”

Jan Riedl, a University of Utah postdoctoral fellow and the study’s first author, says 99 percent of DNA lesions – damage to the chemical bases known as A, C, G and T that help form the DNA double helix – are repaired naturally. The rest can lead to genetic mutations, which are errors in the sequence of bases and can cause disease. The new method can “identify and detect the position of lesions that lead to diseases,” he says.

Burrows says: “We are trying to look for the chemical changes in the base that can lead the cell to make a mistake, a mutation. One of the powerful things about our method is we can read more than a single damaged site [and up to dozens] on the same strand of DNA.”

The chemists say their new method will let researchers study chemical details of DNA lesions or damage. Such lesions, if not repaired naturally, accumulate over time and can lead to mutations responsible for many age-related diseases, including colon, breast, liver, lung and melanoma skin cancers; clogged arteries; and neurological ailments such as Huntington’s disease and Lou Gehrig’s disease.

“A method capable of identifying the chemical identity and location in which lesions appear is crucial for determining the molecular etiology [cause] of these diseases,” Burrows and colleague write in their study.

The new method for finding DNA lesions combines other, existing techniques.

First, the researchers find the damage and cut it out of the DNA the same way a cell does naturally, using what is called “base excision repair,” the discovery of which won a Nobel Prize in Chemistry this year for Tomas Lindahl, a scientist in England.

Second, an “unnatural base pair” is inserted at the snipped-out DNA damage site to label it. Instead of natural base pairs C-G and A-T, the Utah chemists used a so-called third or unnatural base pair invented by chemists at the Scripps Research Institute in California. Burrows says her study demonstrates the first practical use of that invention.

Third, the DNA with the damage site labelled by an unnatural third base pair is then amplified or copied millions of times using a well-known existing method called PCR, or polymerase chain reaction. Burrows says the new study’s key innovation was to use base excision repair to snip out the damage and then to insert the unnatural base pair at the damage site, making it possible to make millions of copies of the DNA – a process that normally would be prevented by the damage.

Fourth, another chemical label, named 18-crown-6 ether, is affixed to the unnatural base pair on all the DNA strands, which are then read or sequenced using a kind of nanopore sequencing developed a few years ago by Burrows and Utah chemist Henry White. Such sequencing involves determining the order and location of bases on a DNA strand – including damage sites labell ed by unnatural bases – by passing the strand through a molecule-size pore or nanopore.

People are born with their genome or genetic blueprint of 3 billion base pairs, “and then stuff happens,” Burrows says. “There’s damage from oxidative stress due to inflammation and infection, too much metabolism, or environmental chemicals.”

The new method seeks “molecular details that define how our genome responds to what we eat and the air we breathe, and ends up being healthy or not,” she says. University of Utah

Neurodermatitis genes influence other allergies

There’s a typical ‘career’ for some allergic people, and it starts very early on the skin: babies develop atopic dermatitis, food allergies may follow, then comes asthma and later on hay fever. A group of scientists led by Ingo Marenholz and Young-Ae Lee at the Max Delbrück Center for Molecular Medicine in the Helmholtz Association (MDC), working with colleagues from several institutions, has now identified seven genetic risk loci for this course of disease. Two of these loci were previously unknown and mainly influence the connection between atopic dermatitis and asthma. According to the study, the regions that determine the risk for atopic dermatitis are mainly those that also determine the risk for the further development of the typical allergic career. This course of disease is also called the ‘atopic march.’ The scientists analysed data from nearly 20,000 people.
For their meta-analysis, the researchers concentrated on cases where atopic dermatitis preceded asthma. They included 12 studies with 2,428 patients and 17,034 healthy people. All of these studies were genome-wide association studies (GWAS) based on millions of genetic variants called Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs).

It is the first GWAS for the atopic march and showed for the first time that there are specific genetic loci influencing the march’s unfortunate course. ‘Seen from a physician’s perspective, the prominent role of atopic dermatitis genes for later-onset of asthma is very interesting,“ says Young-Ae Lee. Max Delbrück Center for Molecular Medicine